Obviously MA's and RN's do different things, but just exactly what are the practical differences? We take a look and answer the question.
The 4 main areas of difference are:
This is the topic that comes up most often, because Registered Nurses typically earn a lot more than Medical Assistants.
The Bureau of Labor and Statistics lists the median salaries for both occupations in 2010 as being:
- Medical Assistant (MA): $28,860 per year (detailed medical assistant salary info here)
- Registered Nurse (RN): $64,690 per year
With Registered Nurses earning more than double what Medical Assistants make, there clearly must be some big differences in the responsibilities of the two roles, so let's take a look...
MA's typically work in small practices and clinics where patients come in for short visits. RN's on the other hand tend to be employed by Hospitals and large clinics where patients may have short visits, but where many of them are also assigned beds and stay through the night.
For Medical Assistants, this means that they are typically able to work a regular 'day job'.
The situation is often quite different for RN's who have to provide patient care 24/7. This translates into a great deal of shift work and 'on-call' sessions where nurses are on stand by in order to respond to calls for additional staff at any time of the day or night.
There is no legally required minimum level of education for a Medical Assistant because no formal qualification is required. However, most MA's these days do want to be certified, and that generally requires between 6 and 12 months of study. It is possible to do longer courses and it can be beneficial in some cases - for a closer look at this issue see our article on Associate Degrees in Medical Assisting.
Becoming a Registered Nurse requires a minimum of an Associate Degree which usually takes at least 2 years to complete, however most RNs will study for a Bachelor Degree. This will generally take between 3 to 4 years to complete, and of course comes with a higher price tag.
Probably the main difference that we often hear of is that RN's have to do a lot more paperwork than MA's. When you think about it, this makes a lot of sense. Nurses have to keep detailed records about patient vital signs at regular intervals, they have to keep precise records of medications - how much and when they were administered, and they usually have many more patients to keep track of.
Here is a brief overview of the basic duties performed in each role:
|Registered Nurse (RN)||Medical Assistant (MA)|
|Administer medicines, injections, and treatments||Administer medicines and injections|
|Consult with doctors and other healthcare professionals||Answer directly to doctors|
|Help perform diagnostic tests and analyze results||Help with diagnostic tests where qualified|
|Operate and monitor medical equipment EG: EKG||Operate medical equipment EG: EKG|
|Record patient medical histories||Take basic patient information prior to appointments|
|Create patient care plans|
|Continuous patient observation - recording the results|
|Council patients on managing their condition|
|Provide guidance on home care post treatment|
This isn't an exhaustive list of differences in duties and responsibilities, however you can see that an RN has a great deal more responsibility than a Medical Assistant.
The take-away points are that RN's earn higher salaries, take significantly longer to gain their qualifications, often have to work longer/irregular hours, and take direct responsibly for their patients, whereas an MA works directly under a doctor who takes most of the responsibility.